Houses Approves Canceled Health Insurance, View Vote Breakdown List

The House on Friday approved a bill to allow insurers to sell canceled health insurance plans that had been canceled due to ObamaCare regulations.

The vote came a day after President Obama announced he would unilaterally attempt to fix the problem, but Obama capitulated after the vote had been scheduled Tuesday.

The bill passed 261-157, with 39 Democrats crossing over to support the GOP-backed legislation (View for the vote breakdown below), who previously supported opposing the effort before and during the government shutdown. Only after Republicans’ predictions that the law would negatively harm Americans coming to fruition, did these Democrats make a politically calculated decision.

The bill approved by the Republican-controlled House would go further than the plan Obama by allowing insurance companies to sell the old plans to customers who previously had them, as well as new customers, but only for another year. Obama’s plan would only apply to those customers enrolled in the plans before the cancellation notices went out.

However, Republicans, in bringing the bill to the floor on Friday, underscored that President Obama does not even have the constitutional authority to make those changes on his own. President Obama previously and unilaterally exempted his crony friends from compliance with the law, which many on the right criticized before the shutdown.

House Speaker John Boehner said he’s “highly skeptical that they can do this administratively.”

The legislation’s sponsor, Michigan Republican and Chairman Fred Upton, also raised the question whether or not Obama could or would simply reverse course a few weeks or months down the road. Upton told Fox News that his bill is a “better answer — because who knows how his executive order is going to be tested?”

President Obama has already vowed to veto the House bill, despite claiming he wants to remedy his broken promise, disguising his opposition with suggestions the bill goes too far. Prior the vote, Republicans turned away a Democratic alternative that would have taken the teeth out of the GOP bill, because it wouldn’t have addressed the real cause of the problem nor its already devastating ramifications.

The bill may be a great gesture, but neither so-called “fix” will actually undo the damage ObamaCare has and will cause. In fact, both are likely to cause problems for the insurance industry and state-level commissioners, further exacerbating the negative impacts of an already-failed law.

Amid Obama’s announcement on Thursday, they complained that they were unsure how to implement the change, if at all, considering cancellation notices have already gone out and rates have already been set for 2014 in many states.

Obama plans to meet with insurance industry executives Friday afternoon, after they fired back at the Obama administration for trying to dump the blame on them.

“What we want to do is to be able to say to these folks, you know what, the Affordable Care Act is not going to be the reason why insurers have to cancel your plan,” Obama said of the millions who have received cancellation notices. But the fact, is that insurers are merely following the law, a law that is designed to throw off those private holders so that high risk pools do not drive up premiums even further.

Only last week, Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius told a Senate panel she doubted that retroactively permitting insurers to sell canceled policies after all “can work very well since companies are now in the market with an array of new plans. Many have actually added consumer protections in the last 3 1/2 years.”

FINAL VOTE RESULTS FOR ROLL CALL 587(Republicans in roman; Democrats in italic; Independents underlined)
H R 3350      RECORDED VOTE      15-Nov-2013      1:34 PM
QUESTION:  On Passage
BILL TITLE: Keep Your Health Plan Act of 2013

 

	AYES	NOES	PRES	NV
REPUBLICAN	222	4		4
DEMOCRATIC	39	153		8
INDEPENDENT
TOTALS	261	157		12

—- AYES    261 — 

Aderholt Amash Amodei Bachmann Bachus Barber Barletta Barr Barrow (GA) Barton Benishek Bentivolio Bera (CA) Bilirakis Bishop (NY) Bishop (UT) Black Blackburn Boustany Brady (TX) Braley (IA) Brooks (AL) Brooks (IN) Brownley (CA) Buchanan Bucshon Burgess Bustos Calvert Camp Cantor Capito Carter Cassidy Chabot Chaffetz Coble Coffman Cole Collins (GA) Collins (NY) Conaway Cook Costa Cotton Cramer Crawford Crenshaw Culberson Daines Davis, Rodney DeFazio DelBene Denham Dent DeSantis DesJarlais Diaz-Balart Duckworth Duffy Duncan (SC) Duncan (TN) Ellmers Enyart Esty Farenthold Fincher Fitzpatrick Fleischmann Fleming Flores Forbes Fortenberry Foster Foxx Franks (AZ) Frelinghuysen Gallego Garamendi Garcia Gardner Garrett Gerlach Gibbs Gibson Gingrey (GA) Gohmert

Goodlatte Gowdy Graves (GA) Graves (MO) Griffin (AR) Griffith (VA) Grimm Guthrie Hanna Harper Harris Hartzler Hastings (WA) Heck (NV) Hensarling Herrera Beutler Holding Hudson Huelskamp Huizenga (MI) Hultgren Hunter Hurt Issa Jenkins Johnson (OH) Johnson, Sam Jordan Joyce Kelly (PA) Kind King (IA) King (NY) Kingston Kinzinger (IL) Kline Kuster Labrador LaMalfa Lamborn Lance Lankford Latham Latta LoBiondo Loebsack Long Lucas Luetkemeyer Lummis Maffei Maloney, Sean Marchant Marino Matheson McCarthy (CA) McCaul McClintock McHenry McIntyre McKeon McKinley McMorris Rodgers McNerney Meadows Meehan Messer Mica Miller (FL) Miller (MI) Miller, Gary Mullin Mulvaney Murphy (FL) Murphy (PA) Neugebauer Noem Nolan Nugent Nunes Nunnelee Olson Owens Palazzo Paulsen Pearce Perry

Peters (CA) Peters (MI) Peterson Petri Pittenger Pitts Poe (TX) Pompeo Posey Price (GA) Radel Rahall Reed Reichert Renacci Ribble Rice (SC) Rigell Roby Roe (TN) Rogers (AL) Rogers (KY) Rogers (MI) Rohrabacher Rokita Rooney Ros-Lehtinen Roskam Ross Rothfus Royce Ruiz Runyan Ryan (WI) Salmon Sanford Scalise Schneider Schock Schrader Schweikert Scott, Austin Sensenbrenner Sessions Shea-Porter Shimkus Shuster Simpson Sinema Smith (MO) Smith (NE) Smith (NJ) Smith (TX) Southerland Stewart Stivers Stockman Stutzman Terry Thompson (PA) Thornberry Tiberi Tipton Turner Upton Valadao Vela Wagner Walberg Walden Walorski Walz Weber (TX) Webster (FL) Wenstrup Westmoreland Whitfield Williams Wilson (SC) Wittman Wolf Womack Woodall Yoder Yoho Young (AK) Young (IN)

—- NOES    157 — 

Andrews Bass Beatty Bishop (GA) Blumenauer Bonamici Brady (PA) Bridenstine Broun (GA) Brown (FL) Butterfield Capps Capuano Carney Carson (IN) Cartwright Castor (FL) Castro (TX) Chu Cicilline Clarke Clay Cleaver Clyburn Cohen Connolly Conyers Cooper Courtney Crowley Cuellar Cummings Davis (CA) Davis, Danny DeGette Delaney DeLauro Deutch Dingell Doggett Doyle Edwards Ellison Engel Eshoo Farr Fattah Frankel (FL) Fudge Gabbard Grayson Green, Al Grijalva

Gutiérrez Hahn Hall Hanabusa Hastings (FL) Heck (WA) Higgins Himes Hinojosa Holt Honda Horsford Hoyer Huffman Israel Jackson Lee Jeffries Johnson (GA) Johnson, E. B. Kaptur Keating Kelly (IL) Kennedy Kildee Kilmer Kirkpatrick Langevin Larsen (WA) Larson (CT) Lee (CA) Levin Lewis Lipinski Lofgren Lowenthal Lowey Lujan Grisham (NM) Luján, Ben Ray (NM) Lynch Maloney, Carolyn Massie Matsui McCollum McDermott McGovern Meeks Meng Michaud Moore Moran Nadler Napolitano Neal

Negrete McLeod O’Rourke Pallone Pascrell Pastor (AZ) Payne Pelosi Perlmutter Pingree (ME) Pocan Polis Price (NC) Quigley Rangel Richmond Roybal-Allard Ruppersberger Ryan (OH) Sánchez, Linda T. Sanchez, Loretta Sarbanes Schakowsky Schiff Schwartz Scott (VA) Scott, David Serrano Sewell (AL) Sherman Slaughter Smith (WA) Speier Swalwell (CA) Takano Thompson (CA) Thompson (MS) Tierney Titus Tonko Van Hollen Vargas Veasey Velázquez Visclosky Wasserman Schultz Waters Watt Waxman Welch Wilson (FL) Yarmuth

—- NOT VOTING    12 — 

Becerra Campbell Cárdenas Gosar

Granger Green, Gene Jones McCarthy (NY)

Miller, George Rush Sires Tsongas