Widget Image
Follow PPD Social Media
Connect With PPD
Friday, September 20, 2019
HomeEditorialsNo Mother Jones, Bill O’Reilly Didn’t Pull A Brian Williams

No Mother Jones, Bill O’Reilly Didn’t Pull A Brian Williams

oreilly-talking-points-holy-war-begins

Mother Jones has accused Bill O’Reilly of misrepresenting events during his time as a correspondent at a level on par with now-disgraced NBC Nightly News anchor Brian Williams. The accusation is a serious one, considering — as our little video demonstrates — Mr. Williams’ misrepresentations are either the result of being a pathological liar or straight-up delusional.

David Corn, the Washington bureau chief for the uber left-wing magazine and author of the article O’Reilly called ” total bullshit,” said the most popular man in cable news “recounted dramatic stories about his own war reporting that don’t withstand scrutiny—even claiming he acted heroically in a war zone that he apparently never set foot in.”

Corn, whom to be fair everyone knows is the left’s go-to media hit man, the man responsible for planting Jimmy Carter’s grandson in order to get the now-infamous “47 Percent” video of Mitt Romney, focuses on Mr. O’Reilly’s role as a CBS correspondent in the 1982 shooting war between Britain and Argentina over the Falkland Islands.

We tend to agree with Mr. Kurtz — insofar as we would also suggest reading the original article on Mother Jones and follow it up with O’Reilly’s response in a piece Kurtz put out today — but also on his analysis.

Mr. Corn not only makes accusations in his argument that are backed up by obfuscating events and O’Reilly’s own comments, but built an argument on the foundation of semantics, rather than some specific story that O’Reilly told about being in and/or on the Falklands during the actual shootout.

That being said, if the story regarding the cameraman bleeding from the ear turns out to be false, and believe us we will find out if it is, then he will have some explaining to do.

“I was in a situation one time, in a war zone in Argentina, in the Falklands, where my photographer got run down and then hit his head and was bleeding from the ear on the concrete,” O’Reilly said in an April 2013 interview with a reporter from the Boston Globe following the Boston Marathon bombing. “And the army was chasing us. I had to make a decision. And I dragged him off…”

While that would be a tall tale indeed, it is still embellishment of an actual event. It’s a far cry from Brian Williams’ repeated verbal detachments from reality. Further, Corn’s own words largely validate O’Reilly’s account of events.

“Thousands took to the streets. Hundreds of troops surrounded the presidential palace,” O’Reilly said during a 2009 interview with a television station in the Hamptons. “I was in the middle of that. A reporter was shot in the legs. People were throwing rocks, bricks, some had guns.”

And that’s pretty much was Corn writes in Mother Jones.

“Dispatches on the protest filed by reporters from the New York Times, the Miami Herald, and UPI note that thousands did take to the street, setting fires, breaking store windows, and that riot police did battle with protesters who threw rocks and sticks,” the article states. “They say tear gas was deployed; police clubbed people with nightsticks and fired rubber bullets; reporters were assaulted by demonstrators and by police; and a photojournalist was wounded in the legs by gunfire.”

Now, the only difference is in whether or not anyone died from their injuries. Our feeling is two-fold. First, if they were willing to shoot at Western reporters at all, then they are willing to shoot their own in the head. And that could be true whether any of those organizations reported on it or not at the time.

Written by
Staff Writing Group

The Editorial Board at People's Pundit Daily (PPD) debates and publishes opinion editorials, and conducts interviews with political candidates to issue endorsements in U.S. elections. The Board at PPD is made up of three permanent members--including Rich Baris, the People's Pundit, himself--and two temporary members.

Latest comments

  • Richard Baris

    Eye for an eye, huh. And I guess that whole journalism thing doesn’t matter anymore.

    • Avatar

      Thats what its all about. The left bashes the right and the right bashes the left making them all hypocrites. Try being independent. When you criticize Obama you’re a redneck racist pig. When you criticize Boehner you are a freegan… Mean while Washington collects a handsome salary with a retirement plan and works a mere 170 days a year.. On our dime

  • Avatar

    Two days latter we find out Mother Jones jumped the gun. They had two days to bask in their glory and now they are back in the basement again.. So now they will pick away at it to look as though O’Reilly truly did lie to save their ass. I knew O’Reilly would prove his “innocents”. He has a target on his back and would never leave a door open that wold destroy his cred.. Its amazing how people spend so much time targeting and bashing a journalist. After producing film, documents and other journalist I think he has won this battle. I guess there was no way the left was going to let Brian Williams go down without “getting even”…. The press is a joke and more often than not the source of many of Americas problems..

leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.